American vs European waterfall is a question of timing. A European, or whole-fund, waterfall pays the general partner (GP) carried interest only after limited partners (LPs) have their capital and preferred return back across the whole fund. An American, or deal-by-deal, waterfall pays carry as each profitable deal is sold, and relies on a clawback if later deals lose money.
This guide compares the two on the same three deals, in a weak fund and a strong one, explains what makes a clawback collectible, and sets out what ILPA recommends. For how the four tiers work in either model, start with our guide to distribution waterfalls.
Key takeaways
- European means whole-fund. All contributions and the preferred return go back to LPs before any carry.
- American means deal-by-deal. The GP can earn carry on each profitable exit, years earlier.
- Same deals, different timing. In our example, the American waterfall pays the GP $6.0 million in year 2; the European one pays nothing until year 5, and in the weak case nothing at all.
- The clawback carries the risk. Under the American model, the GP owes back $6.9 million in the weak case and $4.0 million in the strong one.
- ILPA prefers whole-fund. Its Principles 3.0 call the whole-of-fund model best practice and the all-capital-back structure the best way to minimize clawbacks.
- Hybrids narrow the gap. Deal-by-deal waterfalls that first return capital on all realized deals and make up write-downs behave much more like whole-fund ones.
American vs European waterfall at a glance
| Feature | European waterfall | American waterfall |
|---|---|---|
| Also called | Whole-fund, whole-of-fund, all-capital-back | Deal-by-deal |
| What LPs get back first | All contributions across the fund, plus the preferred return | The capital in the deal being sold, plus its preferred return |
| When carry is paid | After the whole fund clears the hurdle, usually late in its life | On each profitable exit, from early in the fund’s life |
| Clawback risk | Low, by construction | Higher, and dependent on the clawback terms |
| GP economics | Carry arrives later | Carry arrives earlier, which helps the team’s cash flow |
| ILPA view | Best practice | Acceptable with safeguards |
How European and American waterfalls work
The European, whole-fund waterfall
LPs receive 100% of distributions until they have back every dollar they contributed across the fund, for investments, fees, and expenses, plus the preferred return. Only then does the GP’s catch-up start, followed by the carried interest split. Our distribution waterfall guide walks through the four tiers step by step.
The American, deal-by-deal waterfall
Each exit runs its own small waterfall. LPs first get back the capital invested in that deal, often with its share of fees and expenses and the preferred return on it, and the GP then takes its catch-up and 20% of the rest. Losses on other deals do not hold back carry unless the LPA says so, which is why this model needs a clawback.
In real estate deals
Real estate joint ventures often hold a single property, so their waterfalls work deal by deal by nature, with IRR hurdles and a promote for the sponsor. Funds that hold many properties face the same choice as private equity funds. Our distribution waterfall guide includes a real estate example.
Pros and cons of each waterfall model
European waterfall
- For LPs: no cross-subsidization. A loss on one deal reduces the carry from another before any carry is paid.
- For LPs: little clawback risk. The GP cannot be paid carry the fund has not earned.
- For GPs: carry arrives late. Often years after the first exits, which can strain team retention.
- For GPs: J-curve exposure. Fees and early write-downs must be recovered across the fund before carry starts.
American waterfall
- For GPs: earlier carry. Pay follows realized deals, which helps a team paid mostly through carry.
- For GPs: deal-level accountability. Results show up in carry as each deal is realized.
- For LPs: cross-subsidization. Winners pay carry while losses on other deals are not netted, unless the LPA adds loss recovery.
- For LPs: credit risk on the clawback. Recovering overpaid carry depends on the guarantees, the escrow, and the tax terms.
Example: the same three deals under each model
A $100 million fund invests in three companies at the start. Deal A is sold in year 2 for twice its cost, Deal B in year 4 for half its cost, and Deal C in year 5. In the weak case, Deal C sells for $45 million; in the strong case, for $75 million. Both waterfalls use an 8% compounding preferred return, a full catch-up, and 20% carry. Fees are left out to keep the comparison clean.
The three deals ($ million)
| Deal | Invested in year 0 | Sold in | Proceeds, weak case | Proceeds, strong case |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Deal A | 30.0 | Year 2 | 60.0 | 60.0 |
| Deal B | 40.0 | Year 4 | 20.0 | 20.0 |
| Deal C | 30.0 | Year 5 | 45.0 | 75.0 |
| Fund | 100.0 | 125.0 | 155.0 |
Carry under each model ($ million)
| Measure | Weak case, American | Weak case, European | Strong case, American | Strong case, European |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Carry paid by year 2 | 6.0 | 0.0 | 6.0 | 0.0 |
| Carry paid before any clawback | 6.9 | 0.0 | 15.0 | 11.0 |
| Clawback owed at the end | 6.9 | n/a | 4.0 | n/a |
| LP total after a full clawback | 125.0 | 125.0 | 144.0 | 144.0 |
- Year 2: the American waterfall pays carry at once. Deal A clears its own hurdle, so the GP takes $6.0 million. Under the European model, LPs are still short of their capital and preferred return across the fund, so the GP gets nothing.
- Weak case: the European GP never earns carry. Deal B’s loss keeps LPs below the fund-level hurdle. The American GP has already received $6.9 million and must return all of it through the clawback.
- Strong case: both GPs earn carry, but not the same amount. The American GP receives $15.0 million because Deal B’s loss never reduced its carry. On the whole fund it is entitled to $11.0 million, so it owes back $4.0 million.
- LPs end level only if the clawback is paid. With full repayment, LPs receive $125.0 million in the weak case and $144.0 million in the strong case under both models.
Illustrative example. Amounts are in $ million and rounded; each deal’s preferred return compounds from year 0 to its exit.
Model both waterfalls on your own terms
FundCount’s waterfall engine handles deal-by-deal and whole-fund terms, preferred returns, catch-ups, and tiered carry, and posts the allocations to the general ledger.
The clawback: what makes it collectible
Under a deal-by-deal waterfall, the clawback is the LPs’ main protection, and it is only as good as the GP’s ability to pay. ILPA’s Principles 3.0 point to these terms:
- An all-capital-back structure first. ILPA calls it the best way to minimize clawback liabilities.
- A clawback period beyond the fund’s term, including liquidation.
- Joint and several liability of the individual GP members, which ILPA strongly encourages, or a creditworthy guarantee of the full amount.
- Repayment gross of tax, within two years after the liability is recognized.
- An escrow or holdback: part of each carry payment held back until the fund’s final numbers are known.
ILPA’s earlier principles also listed ways to strengthen a deal-by-deal waterfall, such as returning all realized cost on an investment and making up partial impairments and write-offs before carry is paid. In 2020, ILPA added a deal-by-deal version of its Model LPA; law firm Dechert argued that its mechanics will often produce the same timing and amounts as a whole-of-fund waterfall.
Which waterfall protects LPs more?
The European, whole-fund model, by construction: the GP cannot be paid carry the fund has not earned, so there is little to claw back. An American waterfall can come close if it returns capital for all realized deals and write-downs first and backs the clawback with an escrow and joint and several guarantees. Without those, LPs take on the credit risk of the GP’s team for years.
GPs prefer the American model for the opposite reason: carry arrives years earlier, which matters to a team paid mostly through carry. In practice, LPs negotiate the safeguards rather than the label. For how the carry itself is computed, see our guide to carried interest calculation, and for the tier that follows the hurdle, the GP catch-up.
Questions to ask about a fund’s waterfall
- Is the waterfall whole-fund or deal-by-deal, and if deal-by-deal, are realized losses and write-downs returned before carry?
- Are fees and fund expenses returned to LPs before carry on each deal?
- When is the clawback tested: only at the end, or also at interim dates?
- Is the clawback gross or net of tax, and who guarantees it?
- Is any carry held in escrow, and when is it released?
- How much carry has been paid so far, and what would the clawback be if the fund ended today?
How FundCount handles both waterfall models
The difference between the two models is in the terms, not the arithmetic, so the engine has to follow the LPA exactly.
- Partnership accounting includes a configurable waterfall engine that handles deal-by-deal and whole-fund terms, preferred returns, catch-ups, and tiered carry.
- Allocations and GP carry crystallization post to the same general ledger as trades and cash, and distribution and waterfall notices come out of the same records.
- Multi-vehicle waterfalls, partial LP transfers, and side pockets are handled natively, and the investor portal delivers statements and notices to LPs.
For why the waterfall belongs inside the accounting system, see our guide to private equity waterfall software.
Watch-outs
- Clawback and escrow terms vary widely between LPAs. Set them up from the documents and test the results against past notices.
- Hybrid waterfalls need each step configured explicitly, such as which write-downs are made up before carry.
See deal-by-deal and whole-fund carry side by side
In a guided walkthrough, we run a fund’s waterfall under its LPA terms and show the allocations and notices LPs receive.
FAQs
What is the difference between an American and a European waterfall?
A European, or whole-fund, waterfall returns all contributions and the preferred return across the fund before the GP earns carry. An American, or deal-by-deal, waterfall lets the GP earn carry on each profitable deal as it is sold.
Which waterfall is better for LPs?
The European model, because the GP cannot receive carry the fund has not earned. A deal-by-deal waterfall can come close with loss recovery, an escrow, and a well-guaranteed clawback.
Why do GPs prefer American waterfalls?
Carry arrives years earlier, as soon as individual deals are sold at a profit, which matters to teams paid mainly through carried interest.
What is a clawback?
The GP’s obligation to return carry it received but was not entitled to on the fund’s final numbers. It matters most under deal-by-deal waterfalls.
Is the clawback gross or net of tax?
It depends on the LPA. ILPA’s Principles 3.0 recommend gross of tax, repaid within two years after the liability is recognized.
What is a hybrid waterfall?
A deal-by-deal waterfall with added protection, such as returning capital for all realized deals and making up write-downs before carry is paid on the next exit.
What is cross-subsidization in a waterfall?
Under a deal-by-deal waterfall, profitable deals pay the GP carry while losses on other deals are not netted against them, so LPs effectively pay carry on winners out of their losses. Whole-fund waterfalls, and deal-by-deal waterfalls with loss recovery, prevent it.
Is a European waterfall the same as a whole-fund waterfall?
Yes. European, whole-fund, whole-of-fund, and all-capital-back describe the same model.
Does the waterfall type change management fees?
No. Fees are set separately in the LPA, although in a whole-fund waterfall LPs usually get the capital called for fees back before carry.
Sources and methodology
Sources: ILPA Principles 3.0 (2019), sections on waterfall structure and clawback; ILPA’s earlier private equity principles on deal-by-deal waterfalls; Dechert, Updated ILPA Model LPAs (2020); Bryan Cave Leighton Paisner on Principles 3.0. FundCount capabilities reviewed in November 2026.
Examples: fictional and simplified, with no fees. Both waterfalls use an 8% preferred return compounded annually, a full catch-up, and 20% carry. Amounts are rounded.
Scope: general information, not legal, tax, or investment advice. Every LPA defines its own waterfall and clawback.
Published: November 2026.