In private equity, PME stands for public market equivalent: a way to compare a fund’s returns with what the same cash flows would have earned in a public index. It answers the question every LP eventually asks of a private fund: did it beat the market, after fees, given when the money actually went in and came out?
This guide explains why a fund’s IRR cannot simply be compared with an index return, how the main PME methods work, how to calculate KS-PME and direct alpha step by step, how to choose the index, and what PME studies show about buyout funds. The worked example uses Sample Fund IV from our DPI and RVPI guides.
Key takeaways
- PME runs the fund’s cash flows through an index. It compares the fund with what the same contributions and distributions would have earned in the market.
- A KS-PME above 1.0 means the fund beat the index. It is the most widely used form: value out over value in, with every cash flow compounded at the index return.
- Direct alpha turns that into a yearly rate. It is the fund’s annualized excess return over the index, from the same cash flows.
- Long-Nickels gives an index IRR to set against the fund’s IRR. Its index account can run negative when a fund outperforms, which PME+ and mPME were designed to fix.
- The index decides the answer. Use a total return index that matches the fund’s strategy, size, and geography, and name it with every result.
- The evidence is mixed. Bain’s 2026 report shows US buyout funds trailing public markets over 5 and 10 years but ahead over 20, with top-quartile funds ahead throughout.
What is PME in private equity?
Public market equivalent is a family of methods, not one formula. Each takes a fund’s actual contributions, distributions, and latest NAV and asks what the same money would have done in a public index over the same dates. Because it uses the fund’s own cash flows, it respects the timing the GP controlled, which a plain comparison of returns does not.
PME is usually calculated on net cash flows, meaning the LPs’ actual capital calls and distributions, so the comparison is after management fees, fund expenses, and carried interest.
Why a fund’s IRR cannot be compared with an index return
A fund’s IRR is money-weighted: it depends on when capital was called and returned. An index return is time-weighted: it measures one dollar held for the whole period. Setting one against the other compares answers to different questions, as our guide to TWR vs IRR explains. PME fixes this by applying the index to the fund’s own cash flows, so both sides are measured on the same dates.
PME methods compared
| Method | Introduced by | Result | How it works | Watch-out |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Long-Nickels PME | Austin Long and Craig Nickels, 1996 | An index IRR to compare with the fund’s IRR | Buys the index with each contribution and sells it with each distribution | The index account can turn negative when the fund outperforms |
| PME+ | Christophe Rouvinez (Capital Dynamics), 2003 | An index IRR | Scales distributions so the index account ends at the fund’s NAV | The scaling changes the timing being compared |
| mPME | Cambridge Associates, published 2013 | An index IRR | Sells index units in proportion to each distribution’s share of the fund’s value | Needs interim NAVs, so errors in them flow through |
| Kaplan-Schoar PME (KS-PME) | Steven Kaplan and Antoinette Schoar, 2005 | A multiple: above 1.0 means the fund beat the index | Compounds every cash flow at the index return to one date, then divides value out by value in | No time dimension; read it with the fund’s age |
| Direct alpha | Oleg Gredil, Barry Griffiths, and Rüdiger Stucke, 2014 | An annualized excess return | Takes the IRR of the cash flows after compounding them at the index return | Depends on the latest NAV, like every method |
KS-PME and direct alpha use the same inputs and agree on the direction: if one shows outperformance, so does the other. Most LP reports lead with KS-PME and add direct alpha when an annual rate is needed.
How to calculate KS-PME and direct alpha
-
Collect the fund’s cash flows
Every contribution and distribution with its date, plus the latest NAV and its date.
-
Choose the index
Use a total return index, with dividends reinvested, and get its level on every cash flow date and on the valuation date.
-
Compound each cash flow to the valuation date
Multiply it by the index level on the valuation date divided by the index level on its own date.
-
Divide for KS-PME
Compounded distributions plus NAV, over compounded contributions.
-
Solve for direct alpha
Take the IRR of the compounded cash flows, with NAV as the last one.
KS-PME = (Σ Dt × IT ÷ It + NAVT) ÷ (Σ Ct × IT ÷ It), where D are distributions, C contributions, I the index level, t each cash flow date, and T the valuation date.
Direct alpha = IRR of (Dt − Ct) × IT ÷ It, with NAVT added as the final cash flow. It is the yearly rate at which the fund’s value grew faster, or slower, than the index.
Example: Sample Fund IV against an index
Sample Fund IV called $95 million and distributed $156 million over ten years, and has $12 million of NAV left. Its net IRR is 12.7%. Over the same ten years, an illustrative total return index rose 116%, with two down years along the way.
Compounding the cash flows at the index return ($ million)
| Year | Contributions | Distributions | Index level | Factor to year 10 | Contributions at year-10 value | Distributions at year-10 value |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Year 1 | 22.0 | 0.0 | 112.0 | 1.925 | 42.4 | 0.0 |
| Year 2 | 19.0 | 0.0 | 105.3 | 2.048 | 38.9 | 0.0 |
| Year 3 | 17.0 | 4.0 | 124.2 | 1.736 | 29.5 | 6.9 |
| Year 4 | 18.0 | 0.0 | 135.4 | 1.592 | 28.7 | 0.0 |
| Year 5 | 10.0 | 15.0 | 154.4 | 1.397 | 14.0 | 21.0 |
| Year 6 | 5.0 | 19.0 | 138.9 | 1.552 | 7.8 | 29.5 |
| Year 7 | 2.0 | 28.0 | 168.1 | 1.283 | 2.6 | 35.9 |
| Year 8 | 1.0 | 32.0 | 179.9 | 1.199 | 1.2 | 38.4 |
| Year 9 | 1.0 | 33.0 | 199.7 | 1.080 | 1.1 | 35.6 |
| Year 10 | 0.0 | 25.0 | 215.6 | 1.000 | 0.0 | 25.0 |
| NAV at year 10 | 12.0 | 1.000 | 12.0 | |||
| Total | 95.0 | 168.0 | 166.0 | 204.3 |
- KS-PME: 1.23. The fund’s distributions and NAV, compounded at the index return, are worth 23% more than its contributions compounded the same way: $204.3 million against $166.0 million. The fund beat the index.
- Direct alpha: 4.5% a year. That is the fund’s annual excess return over the index, on its own cash flows.
- Long-Nickels: the index account runs dry. Buying the index with each contribution and selling it with each distribution leaves the account at −$26.3 million at year 10, below zero from year 9, because the fund paid out more than the index portfolio could fund. PME+ and mPME were built to avoid this.
Illustrative example. Sample Fund IV and the index are fictional; cash flows are at year-ends, the index includes dividends, and results are rounded.
Run PME on cash flows you can trust
FundCount keeps every capital call, distribution, and NAV dated and reconciled in the books, and sends them to Power BI, your data warehouse, or Excel for any benchmark model.
Choosing the right index
The index decides the answer, so choose it before you see the results and use the same one for every fund of the same strategy.
| Fund strategy | Common index choices |
|---|---|
| US large buyout | S&P 500, total return |
| Small and mid-market buyout | Russell 2000 or S&P SmallCap 600 |
| Global buyout | MSCI World or MSCI ACWI |
| Venture capital | Nasdaq Composite or Russell 2000 Growth |
| Real estate | A listed REIT index |
| Infrastructure | A listed infrastructure index |
| Private credit | A leveraged loan or high-yield bond index |
Use a total return index, with dividends reinvested, in the fund’s currency, and state the index and the valuation date with every PME you report.
How to read a PME, and where it falls short
- Above 1.0, or positive alpha, means outperformance after fees and on the fund’s own timing.
- Compare like with like: funds of the same vintage and strategy, against the same index.
- Interim PMEs rest on NAV. Until a fund is fully realized, the result depends on the latest marks, so it inherits any lag or bias in them. Our guide to Level 3 assets explains how those marks are set.
- PME assumes the fund carries the index’s market risk. Buyout funds use leverage, so some LPs also compare them with a small-cap or levered index.
- Small differences are noise. A KS-PME of 1.02 on a young fund says little.
- A good PME does not pay the bills. Read it with DPI and TVPI, which show how much value has actually come back.
What PME studies show about buyout funds
- Kaplan and Schoar, 2005. In the study that introduced KS-PME, US buyout funds, net of fees, returned slightly less than the S&P 500 on average.
- Harris, Jenkinson, and Kaplan, 2014. Using Burgiss data, they found average US buyout fund returns above public markets for most vintages since 1984.
- Bain, 2026. Using a Long-Nickels PME on MSCI data as of September 2025, Bain shows US buyout funds trailing public markets over 5 and 10 years but ahead over 20, with top-quartile funds ahead across every horizon.
The answer depends on the period, the data, and the index. Calculate PME for your own funds, on your own cash flows, instead of relying on an industry average.
How FundCount supports PME analysis
A PME is only as good as the cash flows and NAVs it starts from. FundCount keeps them in the books, dated and reconciled.
- AI Document Intelligence turns capital calls, distribution notices, and capital account statements into dated, accounting-ready data posted to your books, with the source document attached.
- Portfolio accounting reports IRR, TVPI, DPI, and RVPI per fund and per investor, and calculates time-weighted and money-weighted returns against custom benchmarks on the same positions and cash flows the general ledger posts.
- Reporting sends the same data to Power BI or your data warehouse through native connectors, scheduled extracts, or a REST API, and to Excel, so you can run KS-PME or direct alpha in the model you already use.
The same platform serves family offices that hold many fund interests and the fund administrators that report to LPs.
Watch-outs
- PME needs an index series, ideally total return, from your market data provider. Agree the index for each strategy before comparing funds.
- Results follow the NAVs your GPs report. Use the same valuation date for every fund in a comparison.
See your private funds next to the market
In a guided walkthrough, we show fund cash flows, NAVs, and returns against custom benchmarks, all from one ledger.
FAQs
What does PME stand for in private equity?
Public market equivalent: a family of methods that compare a private fund’s returns with a public index by applying the index to the fund’s own cash flows.
What is a good PME?
A KS-PME above 1.0, or a positive direct alpha, means the fund beat the index after fees. How far above 1.0 is meaningful depends on the fund’s age, its strategy, and the index chosen.
What is the Kaplan-Schoar PME?
The ratio of a fund’s distributions plus NAV to its contributions, with every cash flow compounded at the index return to the same date. Steven Kaplan and Antoinette Schoar introduced it in 2005.
What is direct alpha?
The annualized rate at which a fund outperformed or underperformed the index, calculated as the IRR of its cash flows after compounding them at the index return. Gredil, Griffiths, and Stucke introduced it in 2014.
What is the Long-Nickels PME?
The first PME method, from 1996. It invests each contribution in the index and sells index units for each distribution, then compares the index portfolio’s IRR with the fund’s IRR. Its index account can turn negative when the fund outperforms.
Which index should I use for PME?
A total return index that matches the fund’s strategy, size, and geography, such as the S&P 500 for large US buyout or the Russell 2000 for smaller companies. Use the same index for every fund of the same strategy.
Why not compare a fund’s IRR with the index return?
The fund’s IRR is money-weighted and the index return is time-weighted, so they answer different questions. PME puts both on the fund’s own cash flows.
Is PME calculated net of fees?
Usually, yes. It uses the LPs’ actual contributions and distributions, which come after management fees, fund expenses, and carried interest.
Sources and methodology
Sources: Long and Nickels (1996); Rouvinez (2003); Kaplan and Schoar (2005); Gredil, Griffiths, and Stucke (2014); Cambridge Associates on mPME; as summarized by CFA Institute’s Enterprising Investor (2014) and Buyouts Insider; Harris, Jenkinson, and Kaplan (2014); Bain & Company, Global Private Equity Report 2026. FundCount capabilities reviewed in November 2026.
Examples: Sample Fund IV and the index are fictional. Cash flows are at year-ends; KS-PME, direct alpha, and the Long-Nickels account are computed from the table and rounded.
Scope: general information, not investment advice.
Published: November 2026.